Seeing the World More Clearly

Strategies for unleashing the full moral potential of thought experiments in the Philosophy Classroom

Authors

  • Dominik Balg Tübingen University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.46586/JDPh.2022.9680

Keywords:

thought experiment, intuitions, method of cases, hermeneutical abilities

Abstract

In this paper, I discuss the effects of using thought experiments for the purpose of conceptual clarification of students’ hermeneutical abilities. On the one hand, by providing opportunities to explore the scope of normatively loaded concepts, thought experiments can effectively help students to interpret their social and moral reality more adequately, which in some cases might even help to reduce existing hermeneutical injustices. On the other hand, given their notorious susceptibility to distorting factors that are philosophically irrelevant, they can also push students into accepting idiosyncratic intuitions that they don’t really share and thereby further impair their hermeneutical abilities. After setting out this dilemma in more detail, I will propose various strategies for facilitating the safe use of thought experiments that instructors can use to effectively exploit the empowering potential of thought experiments.

Downloads

Published

2022-05-25

Issue

Section

Articles